Clever Housewife

How to Cook a Turkey in an Oven Bag

by 52 Comments

CB-sponsored-post-white-script-400 How to Cook a Turkey in an Oven Bag and get a super moist turkey with an excellent seasoning blend.

It’s the bird we have to tackle at least once a year – the Thanksgiving Turkey! There are so many ways to cook a turkey, and every year many people have the debate as to which way is the best. I don’t know if there is really one best way, as they all produce different results for different tastes. If you want your turkey fried and breaded, that’s one way to do it, but may not be for everyone. Let’s say you’ve decided on cooking your turkey in the oven. What next? Do you use a foil tent, an oven bag, or nothing at all? So many questions and a variety of answers, but one thing I think we can all agree on is that we want a MOIST turkey. Am I right?

I have had many dry turkeys over the years, and with the time and effort that goes into Thanksgiving meal, nobody wants to be disappointed with that bird, on that day! While I was at cooking school for Reynolds Wrap°, I cooked my first turkey using an oven bag. While you don’t get a nice crispy skin, it produces such a moist turkey. I couldn’t believe it! So, I thought I would help you out with your Thanksgiving Turkey by showing you how to cook a turkey in an oven bag. Thanksgiving Turkey: How to Cook a Turkey in an Oven Bag
We know you want a moist turkey, right? What about a well-seasoned turkey? Seasoning your turkey is super important. There are so many ways to season your turkey, but I find this mix of herbs to be quite tasty

Thanksgiving Turkey: How to Cook a Turkey in an Oven Bag #FreshFinds #shop

If you want to know the great mix of herbs that I use, CLICK HERE!

Now for the instructions on how to cook your turkey in an oven bag, click on over to the next page. 

Click to get the recipe

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Valerie Strawmier says

    Your turkey looks amazing and I really do want to try cooking it in a bag. That sale would be great because I could cook the one I normally do (covered in bacon and butter) and then one in a bag to offer both variations to my family. Thanks for posting such a fun recipe–it looks delicious!

  2. Bonnie says

    I have 2 questions for you. Are there enough drippings to make a gravy and what are baking times for a breast?

  3. Emily Lyon says

    So many drippings Bonnie! I love that about preparing the turkey this way! As for baking times for a breast, I will ask Reynolds and get back to you on that!

  4. Anita Sharp says

    I haven’t done a turkey this way, and it intrigues me!! Why do you put the flour into the oven bag?? Can you use the oven bags if you cook your turkey in an electric roaster? I usually do mine in a roaster, so I can use the oven for the side dishes.

  5. Anita Sharp says

    I haven’t prepared a turkey like this, and it is interesting. Question- Why do you put flour into the oven bag? And can you use an oven bag with an electric roaster? I usually cook my turkey in a roaster so my oven is free to bake the side dishes. Thanks!

  6. Laura says

    I think the turkeys are great in the bag, I’m going to spray it this time. As it did stick to bag using flour. I’m also going to remove bag at least from top of turkey a half hour before done cooking to brown it.

  7. Amy Al says

    I use a bag every year! Love doing it this way no way to mess it up plus it doesn’t take it as long!

  10. Clara says

    This is how my mom always did it! This year is my first time hosting… can you stuff the turkey using this method?

  14. Patty says

    My concern is the cooking time. I have a 24 lb bird and it’s saying 3-3.5 hrs u stuffed. If I cook it out of the bag I’d be more at 5 hours for this size bird. I need to know that 3.5 hours will do it. Thanks

  15. Carol says

    I tried this once and there was so much juice in the bottom of the bag that it wasn’t browned at all, just mealy white skin halfway up the turkey. How can I prevent that.

  17. Kristine Nau says

    I need to know if I can use a oven bag to cook a turkey in a electric roaster pan. I have always used turkey bags in an oven but need to cook three this year for a large dinner and only have space for two turkeys in an oven. The other one needs to be cooked in a roaster pan.

  18. Emily Buys says

    HI Kristine, Unfortunately you cannot use the oven bags in an electric roaster. The same principal applies as if you were to put a plastic bag in a toaster oven – just wouldn’t work. Might you be able to use a neighbor or friend’s oven for your third turkey? You are going to be one busy cook. Happy eating!

  19. darissa says

    Hi Kristine and Emily – I was looking at this recipe with all the great seasonings and I am going to try this! Thanks for the recipe! But not to contradict what Emily says, but I’ve cooked my turkeys in the electric roaster for 20 years, and have always used a bag. I just make sure the bag doesn’t touch the side/top/lid of the electric roaster. I tie it tight. I still use the flour in the bag, and vent it with holes. I place my turkey in a disposable pan, than place it in the electric roaster. Good Luck! tip – I make sure I buy a small enough turkey to fit in my roaster, so that I do have plenty of space so the bag doesn’t touch the roaster. Turns out so juicy! Here is a link about it

    http://www.fsis.usda.gov/wps/wcm/connect/7bba8b70-e0f1-4a15-ba36-68e169d0d08b/Turkey_Alt_Routes.pdf?MOD=AJPERES

    Happy Thanksgiving!

  22. Emily Buys says

    No worries at all Darissa! I’m glad you haven’t had a problem with it thus far. Just because there can be complications, they take precautions so turkeys don’t get ruined or contaminated.

  23. Cindy says

    I also brine my 20 lb turkey for 18 hrs , wash it dry it fresh herbs and butter under the skin , butter and season on the outside , I love using the roasting bag , but since the skin isn’t going to crispy , I lay mine breast side down , and I don’t have to touch it until the roasting time is over , and I leave it rest for 20 minutes ,,, it falls off the bone , is super moist , and the leftovers stay just as moist also , everybody the has had my turkey loves it , and it’s easier then you think , and the clean up doesn’t take long because of the roasting bag ,,,

  25. tracy vernon says

    I use the oven bags every year but this year all the family is coming and have a 27lb turkey. The instructions only go up to 24 lbs. Do you have instructions to use the bag for a larger turkey ? I dont know how much more time to add on.

  27. Emily Buys says

    Hi Shelia, I’m so glad you messaged because it helped me realize my Click here button wasn’t working. The post has been updated so you can “click here” and enter your email address to have the seasonings emailed to you!! Happy cooking!

  28. Emily Buys says

    That is one big turkey, Tracy! From everything I’ve read, I’m guessing the oven bag isn’t recommended for turkeys weighing more than 24 lbs. I would contact Reynolds and ask to be sure, and if they have recommended cooking times for the larger bird. Maybe the bag isn’t quite big enough to accommodate? Either way, good luck!!

  30. Emily Buys says

    I’m not positive about on the roaster, Betty, but I know it’s unsafe to eat turkey that has been left out for more than 2 hours. You don’t want it to dry out by continuing to cook either.

  33. Rhonda Roen says

    Hi Emily,

    I pinned your recipe for ‘how to cook a turkey in an oven bag’ and have tried to click where indicated to have the herb blend recipe emailed to me to no avail. Could you please send it to my e-mail address. I am making a turkey for Easter. Thank you so much! Can’t wait to try your recipe.

    Sincerely,
    Rhonda Roen

  35. Maria says

    I would love the seasoning tecipe for tutkey. This is my first time makeing a turkey & my great grandma’s dressing. I’m a tad nervous to cook for my parents to say the least!

  38. Nancy Copeland says

    Glad to know not to put in electric roaster. Was going to do that. Do you have enough drippings with using the bag?

  41. Betsy Dempsey says

    When I click on the link it doesn’t give me the special seasoning blend. Could you please share it?

  43. Seleta judge says

    Thank you,we have gluten free family members can I use corn starch? Think this has been asked is there enough drippings for dressing and gravy? First time to use bag, thank you again.

  45. Marlene says

    Does the turkey get browned and crispy in the bag? Sounds like a great idea but I like the skin brown and crispy. Also where is the best place t9 put the meat thermometer?

  46. Emily Buys says

    I wouldn’t say the skin gets as brown and crispy as otherwise. The picture is straight from the bag, if that helps. You can always try taking it out of the bag at the end and crisping it up, but I haven’t found it necessary. It gets a certain amount of crispiness on its own. Oven bags need to have slits cut in the top so you can put the thermometer in through there, but I often go by the trusty thermometer that comes with most turkeys and pops out when done. Good luck!

  47. Stacy says

    I’m going to cook my turkey in a bag as you suggested. Question. My oven has a roast setting as well as a bake? And even conventional. which should I be using? Thank you

  48. Lisa Hens says

    I love your Information, Emily. I, too, would like your secret ingredient list. Also, do you have a mailing list? Thanks!

  51. Paula Oddo says

    I always use a bag for my turkey and it turns out great. I have a turkey roaster I use that has a lid. Think I could use the lid on, while cooking the bird in the bag? I never have but
    need the room below, for the sides.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating